| Who they are | Michigan Secretary of State since 2019; former law school dean and election-law attorney. Running mate: State Senate Majority Leader Winnie Brinks (D-Grand Rapids). | U.S. Representative (10th District) since 2023; West Point graduate, Army Apache pilot in Iraq, Detroit businessman. Running mate: State Rep. Jay DeBoyer (R-Clay Twp.), chair of House Oversight, former county elections clerk, and a lumber-business owner. Would be Michigan's first Black governor. |
| Life / abortion | Supports legal abortion; backed 2022 Proposal 3 that put abortion rights in the state constitution. Endorsed by Reproductive Freedom for All. Says she'll make those rights "accessible in all areas of Michigan." | Said in 2018 he is "100% pro-life." Opposed rape/incest exceptions in 2022, then supported them in 2023. Since 2024 says voters "already decided" the issue with Prop 3. Voted for penalties when babies born alive after an attempted abortion aren't given care. |
| Parental rights, schools, faith | Opposes policies that "drain resources" from neighborhood public schools; supports charters held to the same standards. Supports expanding LGBTQ anti-discrimination protections. | Would opt Michigan into the federal tax-credit scholarship program for private and religious schools "on day one." Voted to bar transgender athletes from girls' sports and to require parental consent for gender accommodations at school. Promotes Mississippi's reading model. |
| Economy & cost of living | No middle-class tax hikes; down-payment tax credit for first-time and move-up homebuyers; $5,000 caregiver tax credit; medical-debt relief; cut government costs. Supports unions and the 2040 clean-energy law. Said at the Oct 6 debate she'd support suspending the state gas tax. | Would eliminate the state income tax and reform property taxes; tax credits for workers who move to Michigan and for businesses funding skilled-trades scholarships. Calls the 2040 100% clean-energy mandate "insane." Supports right-to-work. The income-tax repeal would be phased in, not done at once: he'd cut the rate "into the threes" in year one (about $3–3.5B), paid for with audits, unspent funds, and fraud cuts. |
| Immigration & safety | Criticizes federal ICE deployments in Michigan communities; called withholding funds from sanctuary cities "a tool that bullies use." Supported driver's licenses for undocumented immigrants in 2019. Supports red-flag and universal background-check laws. | Voted for more ICE and border funding, a border wall, asylum limits, and E-Verify; opposes sanctuary cities. "Lock up violent criminals." Strong Second Amendment record, including national concealed-carry reciprocity. |
| Health care | "Healthcare should be a right." Wants to restore federal health cuts and expand low-cost preventive care. | "Less government." Voted for the federal bill that cut Medicaid; wants work requirements and fraud reduction; supports rural health access. |
| Religious liberty | No religious-liberty platform found; she left iVoterGuide's religious-liberty questions unanswered. Supported the 2023 civil-rights expansion (sexual orientation and gender identity). It passed without the religious-exemption amendment Republicans offered. | His "parents' bill of rights" protects parents' right to direct children's "moral or religious training … without government burden." His scholarship tax credits could be used at religious schools. No specific conscience-protection proposal found. |
| Endorsed by | Reproductive Freedom for All, Planned Parenthood Advocates of Michigan, Michigan Education Association, UAW, Michigan AFL-CIO, Brady (gun-safety group), Michigan-Ontario Council of Bishops. iVoterGuide rating: "Liberal." | Right to Life of Michigan PAC, National Right to Life, NRA (grade A), Citizens for Traditional Values, Michigan Chamber, Farm Bureau, Police Officers Association of Michigan, Michigan Coalition for Responsible Gun Owners, Michigan Manufacturers Association. iVoterGuide rating: "Conservative." |
| Record & scorecards | No legislative voting record. As Secretary of State she won 57 election lawsuits and lost 5; in some of the losses, courts said she skipped the required rule-making process. NRA grade: F. | Heritage Action 87% this session (74% lifetime). NRA A; Reproductive Freedom for All 0%; AFL-CIO 0%. 2025 votes: yes on the Born-Alive Act, the girls' sports bill, the SAVE Act, and the "One Big Beautiful Bill" (Medicaid cuts plus a one-year cut-off of Planned Parenthood funding). |
| Money | About $12.5M raised and $5.9M on hand (through Aug 24). She and allied groups were set to outspend James on TV about $23M to $1M heading into October. | About $6.4M raised; $1.1–1.5M on hand (sources differ). The pro-James super PAC Mission Michigan had spent $4.7M+ by late July. The Republican Governors Association pulled most of its reserved ad time. |
| Character & integrity | Her husband is a VP at Related Companies, the developer of the Saline data center; its owner, Stephen Ross, is a Benson donor. Her husband pledged to step back from state business if she wins. In 2025 the Attorney General's office said her campaign launch inside a state building broke campaign-finance law, and the state House voted to hold her in contempt over a subpoena. | Disclosed 145 stock trades late, blaming his accountants and a blind trust. A Bridge fact check found his wealth grew mainly from family trusts and the family business, not trading. Has the worst attendance in Michigan's House delegation since 2025. |
| Most criticized for | - Her husband works for the company behind the $43B Saline Township data center. Fact-checkers say he earned no commission, but he was paid $370K last year partly for work on it.
- Running for governor while overseeing the election (she set up a "firewall" plan).
- Republicans attack her record running the 2020 election.
| - Missed about 10% of House votes in 2025, the most of anyone in Michigan's delegation (Detroit News).
- His position on abortion exceptions has changed.
- Democrats point to his stock trades in data-center companies.
- Skipped several primary debates.
|
| Strongest case | Has run a statewide agency for eight years; ahead in the polls; detailed affordability and health-care plans; backed by labor unions. | Military and business background; the biggest tax-cut plan in the race; clearest pro-school-choice and parental-rights record; distances himself from national politics on some issues. |